Thursday, 19 March 2009

WelshPostBox - a put up job?

Most people who read this blog and its ilk (i.e a few Assembly researchers, a few Assembly lobbyists and and a few Assembly journalists - and that's it) will have also read the disturbing, bordering-on-the-criminal intimidation of Luke Ellis at the WelshPostBox blog.

I have too, and one thing about it has become increasingly clear over the past few days - it's a massive put up job.

Whoever is writing this blog has one of two motives - to wind people up, or to implicate someone else for the blog's existence. I rule out number one because there's no humour behind it at all.

So we are left with number two - this is an attempt to make someone look really bad. And lo and behold, the finger of blame has instantly fallen upon Ellis's employer's leadership rival, Huw Lewis and his staff.

Free Speech Wales has led the charge but, to give him credit, he has neither implicated anyone specifically nor has shown any real interest in exposing the identity of the author(s). But the usual array of cybernats have shown no such scruples, piling in with their usual poisionous abuse, smears and speculative accusation.

It's difficult to know what's to be gained by all this pathetic nonsense. Thread contributors tell us this is hurting Huw Lewis's campaign, but it's hard to know if they are just kidding themselves or trying to make it come true.

Now, I have no evidence to back up this theory at all. I have no inside knowledge. Like Free Speech Wales I do not work for a political party, I do not belong to a political party and I do not work in the Assembly. But what I do know is that the bile, smears, personal abuse and general underhand tactics in the Welsh blogosphere come pretty much exclusively from one quarter - the many cybernats who blog and comments on others' blogs.

WPB is so threatening, nasty and OTT that it's only true purpose must be to create a false impression of CyberLewis smear tactics. I don't buy it. This one's got fit-up written all over it.

7 comments:

Juvenal said...

Whoever is writing this blog has one of two motives - to wind people up, or to implicate someone else for the blog's existence. I rule out number one because there's no humour behind it at all.

So we are left with number two - this is an attempt to make someone look really bad. And lo and behold, the finger of blame has instantly fallen upon Ellis's employer's leadership rival, Huw Lewis and his staff.


There are more than two possibilities so you're conclusion is flawed. You're right about ruling out number one though.

Anonymous said...

Lets see Luke Hooligand come out and condem the comments about Luke Ellis then.

I am holding my breath......

Anonymous said...

Glad to see this is being writen by someone else. Clearly not the same guy as the first posts. Still I think you are out of your mind if you think any other parties are behind this. I think other parties would go for Carwyn or Huw but only the nasty New Lab David Taylor types would be as sick to target a staff member in this way

Anonymous said...

You are kidding of course? It is one of the most obvious and pathetic attempts at a stitch-up I've ever seen. And its quite clear from the bias of the links used that its Plaid staff behind it.

The idea of divide and conquer is simple. Unfortunately when it is perpetrated by a simpleton, it all unravels pretty quickly.

Anonymous said...

"You are kidding of course? It is one of the most obvious and pathetic attempts at a stitch-up I've ever seen. And its quite clear from the bias of the links used that its Plaid staff behind it."


Based on what links?

This blog and WPB have really damaged Labour in some of the disgusting things they have said. It is a tad unfair as there is no doubt some nice and decent people working for the party. As a Labour supporter I know a lot of those people at the assembly who do a good job. Still these blogs have been shocking and the sort of things that have been written on WPB are disturbing. Sadly I have also heard them being said in conversation by Labour staff at the Assembly.

Anonymous said...

Everyone already knew you were a Labour staffer but this post just confirms it! The party should seriously consider what sort of staff he is employing. You and Welsh Post Box should be ashamed

Che Grav-ara said...
This comment has been removed by the author.